I’ve been preaching the gospel of going beyond 1st, 2nd and 3rd position by using pentatonic scales in 4th, 5th, and 12th position for years. It’s exciting and frustrating. Exciting to see people light up when they get the idea and run with it. Frustrating because most people give up before they have one of those cosmic breakthroughs that replaces the pain of crashing and burning with the rush of finding uniquely bad ass riffs.
One thing that may hold you back from experimenting more with other positions is that it can be maddening to try to figure out off the top of your head which harp plays what in what position.
So – here you go! – Take a screen shot of this chart and put it with your harmonicas. The next time you are playing in 3rd position, look at the chart and see what harp to grab to try out 5th or 4th position. Songs like “Black Magic Woman” are insanely cool if you play them in 5th position. I ended up making the 3rd, 4th, and 5th position columns reverse type to make it super obvious which positions lean heavily to minor.
I’ll be including a PDF of this chart along with a series of practice drills for pentatonic scales in the six positions on this chart as well as minor pentatonic for second position in a new lesson I’ve formatted for download in the hotrodharmonicas.com store. It also has the most useful variations of train rhythm breathing exercises I have found over the years.
You can find that collection of exercises here It is called “Harmonica Fundamentals: Pentatonic Scales and Train Rhythm Variations”
In the mean time use this chart to take a walk on the wild side next time you are working out a song. You won’t have to hurt your head so much looking for the other harps you could be playing in new ways.
PS – I just did a video in my backyard about improvising with a couple of the pentatonic scales. here it is: